[Depth] The power exchange mode abandoned by Tesla has become a good business in China.
Shai Agassi didn’t bring good news to his team.
The former SAP’s youngest executive director met with waterloo in Better Place, a startup company that created the concept of "power exchange" for electric vehicles. This company, founded by himself, quickly burned out the investment of 850 million US dollars in six years and filed for bankruptcy in 2013.
At the annual meeting of Silicon Valley Index in 2009, Xia Jiaxi, an Israeli with sharp brown eyes, once said ambitiously:
"When you are driving an electric car on the road, when the battery’s power reserve is close to 50%, it will automatically remind you that it needs to be charged, and take you to the nearest Better Place highway charging station with the car’s mobile navigation system. When the car drives into the exquisite’ battery room’ of the charging station, an electric hand will replace the prepared battery with your car. The new battery can support you for at least 160 kilometers. "
This wind of clean energy from Israel was quickly favored by Renault-Nissan Alliance.
At the end of 2010, the car company that launched the Nissan LEAF, once the best-selling electric car in the world, developed a four-door medium-sized electric car-Fluence Ze for Better Place. Xia Jiaxi calculated that by the end of 2015, 100,000 Fluence ZE electric vehicles would be sold in Israel and Denmark.
The highlight of Fluence ZE is not its long body, but its complementary energy design that supports "changing electricity".
But the Danes have no interest in this new car. The final sales volume of Fluence ZE was only 1,400 units, which directly led to a loss of $500 million for Better Place.
Carlos ghosn, the former CEO of Renault-Nissan Alliance, gave Better Place the most menacing blow. He said in public:
"The power change mode is A dead end. After Fluence ZE, Renault gave up the electric car with the power-changing mode. "
Fluence ZE, who was left out in the cold, brought Better Place to a deadlock. In order to solve the common "mileage anxiety" of electric vehicle users at that time, Xia Jiaxi built 1,000 charging stations and 54 switching stations in Israel and Denmark, and invested in a series of demonstration projects in Yokohama, Tokyo, San Francisco Bay Area and Dutch airport.
The infrastructure for electric vehicles is expensive and has no benefits in the short term. The cost of a power station is as high as 500,000 US dollars. Including the maintenance fee, the cost of a power station easily exceeds 1 million US dollars. This move quickly dried up Better Place’s cash flow.
Better Place also tried the possibility in China.
In 2010, it cooperated with Chery to develop electric vehicles with replaceable batteries. In 2011, it signed a strategic cooperation agreement with China Southern Power Grid on the mode of power exchange, and set up an experience center in Guangzhou.
However, BYD, the giant of electric vehicles in China, is more determined in charging mode, which makes Xia Jiaxi a headache.
"BYD runs through the entire industrial chain from complete vehicles to batteries, motors, electronic controls and even charging piles. We only provide one service link. " Xia Jiayu said.
In 2012, the Development Plan of Energy-saving and New Energy Vehicle Industry completely shattered Xia Jiaxi’s dream, and the plan determined the charging path as the main development direction of China’s new energy vehicles. In the context of Xia Jiaxi, China changed from a "Better Place" where milk and honey flowed to a "Bitter Place" that was hard to swallow.
In 2013, Better Place’s power exchange business was withdrawn from Tesla’s home-the United States. The us government immediately made up the last knife and will not promote the power exchange model.
Better Place did not enter the expected growth curve of hockey stick, but fell all the way. Six years later, this once high-spirited startup company had to face the painful reality of bankruptcy.
The fresh air from Israel was condensed in the winter of 2013, leaving a broken picture of "power exchange mode".
In the second month after the fall of Better Place, elon musk, the founder of Tesla, released a "power exchange technology" in the United States, which can be completed in 93 seconds.
In the three minutes when an Audi A8 fuel tank was full, two Tesla Model S were fully charged and revived.
On that day, Musk’s unique blushing face in Pretoria, South Africa, became more and more red with excitement.
But this one is bright and faded quickly.
At the beginning of 2015, Tesla put into trial operation at the first power station near the California Super Charging Station, and invited 200 Model S owners to participate in the test, but in the end only five people were willing to give Musk face.
Because of the single power exchange cost of 60 to 80 dollars, it is still too expensive for the owners of Tesla-even though most of them are newly rich silicon valley technology upstarts.
Moreover, the car after power replacement is mainly replaced with the original battery on schedule. This made Tesla fans shout "stupid and inefficient".
In contrast, the Tesla super-charged pile adjacent to the power exchange station can charge half of the Model S in 20 minutes, costing zero dollars.
The super charging pile will change the power station at that time and beat the water out of the water.
"Tyrant" Musk had to take a shot and personally cut off "changing electricity". He said:
"The utilization rate of the power exchange service is so low that I didn’t expect it. Most car owners are still willing to choose a more widely distributed super charging station, where they can drink coffee and have a rest while charging."
Elon, fascinated by Xia Jiaxi’s vision of "changing electricity", looks like a reckless and reckless teenager. Musk, who was firmly punched by reality, regained his reason, immediately stopped the loss and got away with it.
This is the second death of "changing electricity". Shorter than the first time.
At the Chongqing International Auto Show in June 2020, Qin Lihong, co-founder and president of Weilai Automobile, shared a data:
"As of today, Weilai has deployed 133 power exchange stations in China, and each power exchange station serves more than 70 vehicles on average, providing services for vehicles around 5 to 10 kilometers. Weilai Power Station provides 500,000 power exchange services in the real environment. "
"It has stood the test of the world." Qin Lihong said.
This figure is 10 more than the 123 power stations announced by Shen Fei, vice president of Weilai Power Management in March this year. Even counting the 50 seats expected to land this year, the total number is only 173, which is still 927 seats away from Weilai’s idea of "building 1,100 power stations nationwide in 2020".
Wei Lai’s first demonstration of power exchange was in the Wukesong Gymnasium in Beijing on December 16, 2017. Li Bin, the founder, spent the hardest 2 minutes and 56 seconds in his life, and announced that "it is more convenient to add electricity than to refuel".
Although the power exchange and walking speech, PPT full of spikes and subversive flavor everywhere were interpreted by the outside world as another eye-catching marketing method of Weilai, this did not prevent Weilai car owners from being fans and lovers of power exchange behavior.
The actual use of Weilai power exchange is completely in line with Better Place’s expectation: the owner of electric vehicle can find the nearest power exchange station through the vehicle network or mobile APP, and arrive at the power exchange station at the specified time after paying an appointment. The mechanical arm under the bench will replace the battery pack on the chassis accurately and efficiently.
"This is the only way to replenish energy that can be compared with fuel car refueling." A Weilai car owner said.
This statement was quickly denied by another Weilai car owner. "It is much more convenient to change electricity than to refuel." He said.
In 2018, Weilai opened its 18 power stations on the Beijing-Hong Kong-Macao Expressway: from Doudian service area in Beijing to Houjie service area in Shenzhen.
Each power exchange station located in the high-speed service area keeps a distance of about 150 kilometers, the nearest is 111 kilometers from Pingjiang service area to Leiyang service area, and the farthest is 211 kilometers from HengShi Shui service area to Houjie service area. During the 2300-kilometer journey from Beijing to Shenzhen G4, Weilai owners can change the electricity all the way without wasting a minute on charging.
"Power exchange is a new way to replenish energy for electric vehicles. The penetration rate of Weilai Power Exchange is 48.1%, and nearly half of the car owners have used power exchange services." Shen Fei said, "But the most cost-effective and convenient thing is to use exclusive piles at home."
Li Bin defined power exchange as the core element of Battery as a Service(BaaS) in Weilai. In the conference call of the fourth quarter of 2019, he gave an explanation:
"With Weilai’s ability to exchange electricity and the deployment of power stations across the country, only Weilai in the world can open all the electricity and turn it into a rechargeable, replaceable and upgradeable battery pack."
On April 23, 2020, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, the Ministry of Science and Technology and the Development and Reform Commission jointly issued the Notice on Improving the Financial Subsidy Policy for the Promotion and Application of New Energy Vehicles (hereinafter referred to as the Notice).
One of the clauses is particularly eye-catching:
Vehicles with a price of more than 300,000 yuan (including 300,000 yuan) before subsidies for new energy passenger cars will no longer enjoy preferential policies, and vehicles with "power exchange mode" will not be affected by this regulation.
This clause is interpreted as the Weilai power exchange mode has been officially stamped and approved.
At the subsequent National People’s Congress, Miao Wei, Minister of the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, expressed his high recognition of the power exchange model. He said:
"On the demand side, encourage the development of power exchange mode and encourage local governments to use more new energy vehicles in the field of public services. On the user side, the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology will continue to increase the construction of charging and replacing infrastructure and encourage all kinds of charging and replacing facilities to achieve interconnection. "
During the two sessions this year, the "Government Work Report" expanded "building charging piles" to "adding charging piles, changing power stations and other facilities", which was formally included in the new infrastructure category. This is the first time that "changing power stations" has been written into the government work report.
Power exchange, a rather subversive business model, has passed the 1.0 stage of "symbolic value surpassing the industry itself" in China, and turned into the 2.0 stage of "maximizing profit from scale operation".
Beiqi New Energy, which started the pre-research of power exchange technology in 2011, has upgraded the power exchange station from version 1.0 to version 4.0.
"A power station may have been 150 square meters before, or even occupied a large area. Now, the area of a power station has been reduced to 70 square meters," said Wang Chunfeng, deputy general manager of BAIC Blue Valley Marketing Service Co., Ltd. "At present, we have opened 187 power stations in 19 cities, with a total mileage of 690 million kilometers."
According to the data of Economic Observer, from January 1 to June 8 this year, the number of newly registered power exchange-related enterprises and self-employed households reached 3,432, an increase of 515% compared with 558 in the same period last year. In 2018, the number of power exchange enterprises was 5,781, and in 2019 it was 7,106. As of June this year, the number was 10,466.
According to the data from China Electric Vehicle Charging Infrastructure Promotion Alliance (EVCIPA), as of December 2019, the total number of public charging piles and private charging piles in China was 1.219 million, and the total number of power exchange stations was 306.
In addition to Weilai, which successfully passed through the revolving door of power exchange, and Beiqi New Energy, which has long adhered to the position of power exchange, the attitude of car manufacturers towards power exchange has also begun to change dramatically.
Geely, a local automobile manufacturer in China, registered a new trademark "Easy Power Exchange". As a wholly-owned subsidiary of Geely Technology, Easy Power Exchange just completed its name change last year.
Liu Jinliang, president of Geely Technology Group Co., Ltd. and chairman of Cao Cao Travel, said at the global future travel conference last year that Cao Cao Travel would customize a professional network car with charging and replacing electricity.
Obviously, car companies want to take a share of the power exchange model.
Wang Binggang, head of the national expert group on innovative engineering of new energy vehicles, calculated the profit of power exchange. He learned from the data of Guangzhou Aodong Electric Bus Company that:
If each power station can share 70-80 vehicles on average and change power more than 200 times a day, it will be profitable.
"I think this thing can be done." Wang Binggang said.
This has reassured more car manufacturers who are eager to try outside the door.